Problems of intercultural communication in professional activity of designer
Опубликовано в Молодой учёный №10 (90) май-2 2015 г.
Дата публикации: 10.05.2015
Статья просмотрена: 58 раз
Линькова Т. И., Муслимова Л. И., Писаренко М. И., Шепетовский Д. В. Problems of intercultural communication in professional activity of designer // Молодой ученый. 2015. №10. С. 1494-1496.
Key words: globalization, intercultural communication, design, cultural values, cultural differences, clothes, color symbolism.
We are living in the fast-developing modern world. Nowadays globalization and the Internet allows us to interact with a widely diverse people, whether in the professional field or at leisure. However, we should remember that globalization does not erase all cultural features. Sometimes we have to deal with someone who has completely different culture, different from ours. To establish understanding and make a fruitful collaboration with such person, we need to consider differences in the value system of a partner, to understand all the nuances of the culture inherent to this man. Misunderstanding and ignorance of the most common modern cultures and their peculiarities can lead to misinterpretation of actions or speech, misunderstanding, and curious situations.
Now we can consider freelancing as the most modern and popular way of working. Freelancer is a private specialist. Freelancing is especially common in such areas as journalism, law, computer programming, architecture, design in all its forms, translation, photography and videography, various expert and advisory activities. The most common way to offer freelancer services is Internet. That is why the customers could be totally different people, even from other continents, and consequently belonging to other cultures.
For example, a freelancer who works in design sphere received an order to design a batch of greeting cards for the holiday Fitr Eid al-Fitr. The customer was some citizen of the United Arab Emirates. From the fact that the freelancer had no experience in creating art products for the customer, who professes Islam, he probably could make impermissible and even abusive mistakes, like portraying a happy family which celebrates holidays, or depicting some funny animal. It is prohibited for Muslims to create any image of man or animal to avoid possible idolatry and polytheism. Another reason to prohibit images of living creatures according to Sharia is to prevent a person with their creativity to compete with Allah. Islam believes that the creation of a living being is Allah`s mission, He is the Creator. Man, if he depict a living creature (sculpture or portrait), will never be able to animate it and set in motion. So, it is a strongly entrenched cultural value in Islamic countries.
Thus, freelancer may commit some mistakes because of his inexperience and incompetence and ignorance of the basics of modern culture. Creating a product the designer shall be guided not only by their imagination, but shall know and consider at least basic facts of national history and the history of other nations , it will allow them to avoid fatal errors, sometimes insulting the values of other cultures. Therefore, it is important to have knowledge about the features of different cultures, in our information age, especially if you are dealing with foreign clients or employees at work.
This situation is more than hypothetical and we may show real life examples of intercultural misunderstanding in wider areas, such as the fashion industry, advertising, television series.
Even the professionals can make mistakes. In 1994 the famous fashion house Chanel has released a dress with the image of the Arabic text on the corset. This caused a big outrage, as it turned out the inscription on the dress was taken from the Quran. Such way of using quotes from the holy book was insulting for Muslims. The designer of the fashion house, Karl Lagerfeld was shocked by this news, because he believed that the inscription on the dress quoted some love poem. However, he immediately apologized .
Another incident occurred with Nike and organization CAIR (Council on American-Islamic Relations) in 1997. Cause of the incident was a design of the Nike sneakers. The logo on the sneakers looked like the word «God», which caused outrage among Muslims. The company Nike apologized and promised to withdraw all products that might lead to such incidents. «We hope that Nike will be now aware of the sensitive market that they have and the global issue that pertains with the shoes, «said Nihad Awad, executive director of CAIR .
Such confusions could be avoided if the manufacturer knew the basics of cultural specificities  of its consumers. That is why the large companies that focused on the broad markets should deal with great responsibility and they must think carefully about their products. Because it is meant for a wide range of consumer and therefore, they will be judged by people with different mentalities and points of view. Such misunderstandings appear not only with Islamic culture, but also with other cultural groups. Real example of the failure in the market because of cultural illiteracy is the case occurred with cosmetics company Revlon, which factories located in 22 countries. The company has launched a perfume with the camellias aroma. In Brazil, these flowers are used for ritual purposes, and therefore the sale of these perfume had no success .
Also, it is possible to assume the situation with a freelancer who was never interested in Japanese culture, received an order for souvenirs from a Japanese customer, postcards for example. Freelancer designed a postcard remembering all the associations with Japan. It depicts bowl of rice with chopsticks which vertically stuck into it. For people who are not interested in Japanese traditions such postcard would not seem strange or unpleasant. But for Japanese people such a postcard would be completely unacceptable, because in Japan, a bowl of rice and chopsticks stuck in it, is traditionally part of the meal that accompanies a funeral service. Of course such confusion will most probably lead to loss of client.
We could avoid such errors, if the manufacturer and the performer approach more responsible to work, select materials, which appropriate to the needs of the consumer, and not contrary to its traditional cultural contexts. Designer of clothes for the international market shall consider difference in color coding in different nations [1, 6] and shifts in it through time. For example, in the Western culture white color is considered a color of joy and purity, we see white wedding dresses, the most formal wear for men is so called white tie combining white shirt and white tie with black trousers and black tailcoat in contrast to a bit less formal black tie. We even consider wedding dresses of color different from white to be a deviation. On the other hand, in the Eastern countries white is the color of mourning, so traditional Chinese peasant coming to Shanghai and seeing cosmopolitan (i.e. westernized) locals celebrating wedding with the bride in white may look confused. Traditional bride clothing in China is red, which may be seen as a traditional symbol of remarrying widow by the dying breed that is conservative European. As has been previously said, misunderstanding and ignorance of the features of different cultures can lead to various conflicts. As an example we can consider the popular media franchise “Pokemon “, which was created in 1996 by Satoshi Tajiri. The images, which shown in this cartoon, has caused a number of claims related to religion, racism, cruelty to animals, gambling, etc. For example, some images of pokemon were perceived in the USA as the embodiment of racial stereotypes associated with African Americans. Namely, it was Jynx pokemon, with black skin and big lips. For Japanese mentality such comparisons are not typical. The Japanese people did not see anything offensive in this kind of images. However, in the American version of the series they still had to recolor the character purple .
Great importance should be given to both images used in advertising of product, and the product itself. It is important to consider that at first sight innocuous images can be perceived as an act of racism. Vivid examples in history are, for example, the popular stereotype in our time that Afro-Americans are very fond of watermelon, so any images of a happy black necessarily contains a scene of eating this fruit .
Even, in the 19th century images on posters Blackface became popular — theatrical makeup which was used to represent a black man, that contributed to the spread of stereotypes such as «happy-go-lucky darky on the plantation» or the «dandified coon» .
Attitude to racism and sexism is different in different cultures. There we can give an example with our freelancer who has received an order from the USA to create of video about the different categories of citizens, who are driving a car. Freelancer decided to base this video on a Russian stereotype that women drive car worse than men. This video won’t cause the disturbance in Russia but in the USA and European countries such video would be offensive and derogatory to women. Therefore, to avoid such confusion, you should pay attention to the peculiarities of mentality and value system of the consumer.
Peculiarities of different cultures are important aspects in various types of professional activities, more so if the job includes direct contact with the customers of different cultures, which is frequent situation for free-lance designers. The development of communication systems facilitated globalization, but it can't erase the cultural features of different nations. In one culture, one symbol will be perceived good, as the other, it can cause a storm of discontent. Therefore, the designer's work is to pay respect to local tradition, and to know and respect other national traditions. Only then, we can talk about the really high-quality design, demanded in the worldwide. Most importantly, meet the needs of all cultures. From the above we can make a conclusion that intercultural communication is very important in today's world. To avoid misunderstanding, curious situations and conflicts they should be taken into account.
1. Аксёнова Н. В., Бадмаева Д. В. Бурятская национальная одежда как способ укрепления национальной идентичности // Молодой ученый. — № 21 (80). — 2014. — С. 731–732.
2. Joe O'Shea. Claudia Schiffer and the Satanic Breasts (04/10/2013). URL: http://www.independent.ie/style/fashion/claudia-schiffer-and-the-satanic-breasts-29630821.html (date of access: 15.04.2015)
3. Nike and Islamic group end logo logjam (21/11/1998). URL: http://edition.cnn.com/US/9811/21/nike.islamic/ (date of access: 15.04.2015)
4. Аксёнова Н. В. Английский мир в творческой системе Е. И. Замятина. Автореф. дис. …. канд. филол. наук: 10.01.01 / Аксёнова Наталия Валерьевна. — Томск, 2015. — 22 с.
5. Abdullah Al Jubayer. International marketing mistakes (12/07/2012). URL: http://www.slideshare.net/prince_dj_81/international-marketing-mistakes (date of access: 15.04.2015)
6. Аксёнова Н. В. Символика цвета в повести Е. И. Замятиа «Островитяне» // Коммуникативные аспекты языка и культуры. XII Международная научно-практическая конференция студентов и молодых ученых / под ред. С. А. Песоцкой. — Томск: Изд-во Томского политехнического университета. — 2012. — Ч. 1. — С. 240–244. (date of access: 15.04.2015)
7. Pokemon controversy (31/01/2015). URL: http://bulbapedia.bulbagarden.net/wiki/Pok %C3 %A9mon_controversy#Racism (date of access: 15.04.2015)
8. Watermelon stereotype, Wikipedia URL: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watermelon_stereotype (date of access: 15.04.2015)
9. Blackface, Wikipedia URL: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackface (date of access: 15.04.2015)