Keywords: scheduling algorithm, time reserve, optimization, network diagrams, risk, resource schedule, resource leveling.
1. Introduction
One of the most important social tasks is to provide each family with individual housing which leads to an increase in construction products. As stated in the handbook of critical technologies and promising areas of science and technology of the Russian Federation, one of the most promising directions is «Development and implementation of standard electronic formalized models providing analysis and reengineering of production processes ". For the development of electronic models organizational and technological model of construction should be used in the form of detailed schedules subject to operational variant regulation.
2. Literature Review
According to [1, 2, 3] schedules have been used since the last century in the form of a line graph, proposed by F. L. Gant. In the mid- 30s A. I. Nerovetsky and S. M. BUDNIKOV offered a new form of the timetable — the cyclogram, and at the end of the 50s J. E. Kelly and M. R. Walker put into practice Works directed graphs — network diagrams. Currently, the most progressive method of scheduling is the line method. In the practice of mainstreaming of construction there are different formulations of the problem of Calendar Planning, which according to the classification proposed in the works of V. A. Afanasiev [4,5] differ in composition of initial data, constraints and structure. There are authors [6] who are considering construction crew as the organizational structure with the constant number, qualification and professionalism. In such cases, the team will perform work only on objects of the same type with the same structure and the volume of work performed. [7] provides one of the mathematical models, which addresses the complex task to consolidate teams to objects, minimize inconsistencies resulting from the difference between the need for workers with their actual presence. This paper does not consider planning team (dividing it into Complex and Specialized teams) and especially in the work units, which means absence of proper Labour Organization.
Thus, from the above publications it can be concluded that not all aspects of managing by workers and work units in the complex teams were studied.
3. Generalities
Hitherto with the Calendar Planning of construction works it is hard to find the size of labor and technical resources needed to carry out the work [8]. Equally complicated task for managers is to determine the minimum required amount of resources to perform the work.
Development of construction schedule and timetable of resources with the proposed method.
Object building is 22 -story brick house in a residential complex «My City». It is a rectangular building consisting of 2 sections, with overall dimensions of 55,30 x16,90m. Structural system is cross — wall type with transverse and longitudinal load-bearing walls. Object address: Leningrad region, Vsevolozhsk district.
Table 1
Feasibility indicators
Construction Area |
1076,05 m2 |
The total building area |
15 265,3m2 |
Total area of apartments |
12 515,2m2 |
Building volume |
51 925,7m3 |
Including underground part |
2293,4m3 |
Based on the method of calculation to determine the quantitative composition of the integrated brigades:
- Shifts of works
- Composition of team
- Number of workers by occupations
- Coefficient of productivity
where Mc is normative number of shifts when lifting prefabricated structures;
Cp is the time of performance of work according to the original schedule;
O is quantity (volume) of output;
DH is the normative labor brigade as a whole;
T is Work hours (time spent on production of a given amount of products);
Chs is working hours per shift.
According to the above formula an integrated team of installers should work in shifts.
Strength of the team is people per shift, three shifts is 60 people.
Distribute human resources along the work units as specified in Table 2.
Table 2
Distribute human resources along the work units
№ |
Professions |
Number ofworkers |
1 |
rigger |
|
2 |
concreter |
|
3 |
fitter and welder |
|
4 |
Insulator |
|
5 |
plasterer |
When optimizing the original schedule shifting of workers of noncritical work to those of critical work is made. There is a direct relationship between human resources and time. Using mathematically grounded move of human resources, implementing time reserves for simpler work we shorten the duration of critical works. Transform fragment of bay from timetable in Figure 1 to network. Estimated parameters of network schedule are provided in Table 3.
Table 3
Calculation ofnetwork schedule
№ |
Type of work |
work code |
Labor all workers (man days) |
1 |
Electric welding |
2–10 |
100 |
2 |
Installation of bearing cross walls |
2–3 |
30 |
3 |
Sealing of joints |
2–11 |
70 |
4 |
Installation of staircases |
3–4 |
10 |
5 |
Installation of garbage chute |
4–5 |
15 |
6 |
Installation of internal longitudinal panels |
5–6 |
35 |
7 |
Installation of sanitary cabins |
6–7 |
5 |
8 |
Installation of exterior panels |
7–8 |
45 |
9 |
Installation of ventilation units |
8–9 |
3 |
10 |
Mounting slabs |
9–14 |
17 |
11 |
Concrete work |
11–12 |
75 |
12 |
Stuccoing |
12–13 |
53 |
The most effective solution of reallocation of resources can only be achieved with due regard to the ratio of intensity of noncritical work, from which resources are removed. The largest coefficient indicates that the period of execution of this work compared to that of other uncritical work is tighter. Find that the critical-path length is 160 hours. As a rule this path is to install structures. There are three non-critical paths, these are associated works. Ratio of hard work time and time reserves are shown in Table 4. Due to these reserves installers’ team may be strengthened and hence the critical path is reduced.
Table 4
Time reserve and coefficient of work intensity
№ |
Path of noncriticalworks |
Time reserve |
Coefficient of intensity |
1 |
11,12,13,14 |
92 |
0,36 |
2 |
2,11,14 |
80 |
0,43 |
3 |
2,10,14 |
50 |
0,66 |
According to the original schedule the following composition of integrated team is provided. Allocation of labor along the teams Table 5
Table 5
Composition of integrated team of installers per the initial schedule
Team № |
Professions |
Number (people) |
Separation by shifts |
||
I |
II |
III |
|||
1 |
tower crane operator |
3 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
rigger |
6 |
2 |
2 |
2 |
|
installer of structures |
12 |
4 |
4 |
4 |
|
electric welder |
6 |
2 |
2 |
2 |
|
2 |
insulator |
6 |
6 |
- |
- |
3 |
concreter |
13 |
13 |
- |
- |
4 |
plasterer |
13 |
13 |
- |
- |
Team of installers of structures consists of 12 people, work allows to strengthen team of installers of each shift with up to 7 people, thus increasing the overall composition of team to 21 people. According to the original timetable duration of installation work is 65 hours, and with increasing of assemblers to 21, work is reduced to 37 hours thereby reducing the estimated reserve of time of each team by 65–37 = 28 hours. Reserve of time in the team of insulators is 80–28 = 52 hr, or 65 % of the duration of work. Thus, the number of workers in the team can be reduced to 6 x 0.65 = 3 people. Reserve of time for concrete workers and plasterer is 92–28 = 64 hours, or 69 % of the duration of work. In a similar way we determine that the number of workers in a given team can be reduced by 26 x 0.69 = 18. Considering the rate of redistribution of resources integrated team structure according to optimized network schedule is shown in Table 6.
Table 6
Composition of integrated team of installers according to optimized schedule
Team № |
Professions |
Number (people) |
Separation by shifts |
||
I |
II |
III |
|||
1 |
tower crane operator |
3 |
1 |
1 |
1 |
rigger |
6 |
2 |
2 |
2 |
|
installer of structures |
21 |
7 |
7 |
7 |
|
electric welder |
6 |
2 |
2 |
2 |
|
2 |
insulator |
5 |
5 |
- |
- |
3 |
concreter |
8 |
8 |
- |
- |
4 |
plasterer |
10 |
10 |
- |
- |
Having defined duration of work based on the new number of teams, we develop optimized network schedule.
4.Conclusion
Development of modern methods of modeling of the plans of construction and installation works, methods and algorithms that help effectively make the optimization of resource allocation is an important and urgent task.
Due to sealing of working time and best use of reserves of time, the construction period is reduced; elaboration and wages increase.
References:
1. Afanasiev, V. A. Organization and planning of building production / V. A. Afanasiev // Inline organization of work: a training manual — 5–7 p.
2. Burkov, V. N. The network model and control problems / V. N. Burkov — M: Soviet radio, 1967. — 160 p.
3. Chichaev, V. V. Thread-safe, high-speed method of work organization: abstract. Diss. Prof. the technology. of Sciences. — M, 1949. -18 p.
4. V. A. Afanasiev the Design for building complex systems work: Textbook. manual / Leningrad. ing. — builds. in-so-Leningrad, 1981
5. Ahjuga, X. Network management practices in the design and manufacture of Agricultural Ahjuga. — translated from English. — M: Mir, 1979. — 583 p.
6. Budnikov, MS Basis stream construction / MS Budnikov, P. I. Recent, V.I. rybalskaya. — Kyiv, — 1961. — p.
7. Zarenkov, V. A. Modern constructive decisions, technologies and management methods in construction / V. A. Zarenkov, A. Panibratov — Spbgasu. M; SPb.: Stroyizdat St., 2000. 335 p.
8. Bolotin, S. A. Rationalization of methods of calculation of flows with continuous use of resources and the form of their presentation in the form of schedules / S. Bolotin, P. Kuchanov // Organization, planning and management of construction: meiwes. Temat. Sat. works. — Leningrad: LISI. — 1983. — p. 25–35
9. Benoist T. Subcontractor sheduling on residential.Buildings construction sites / Quenten en Yvelines Frans 2006. — e-lab — Bouygues SA 1 av/ Eugene Freyssinet.
10. Abdallah Elkhyari, Christelle Gueret, and Narendra Jussien. Constraint programming for dynamic scheduling prob- lems. In Hiroshi Kise, editor, ISS’04 International Scheduling Symposium, pages 84–89, Awaji, Hyogo, Japan, May 2004. Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers
11. Volkovinsky, I. Z. Organization of work in integrated teams of network schedules / IV Volkovinsky. — M: stroiizdat-1968. — S. 33–34